Jim Mahoney Director, Screenwriter Melissa Fumero Nina Actor Rachel Bloom Chelsea Actor Luka Jones Allen Actor Julian Gant Actor Dot Marie Jones Elena Actor Vik Sahay Dick Actor Daniel Dorr Actor Hope Lauren Actor Patrick Byas Tyler Actor Shontae Saldana Jaz Actor Caroline Harris Tiffany Actor Greg Rencken Bar Patron Actor David Carzell William Actor James Harris Producer Mark Lane Producer Sarah Gabriel Producer Marc Goldberg Producer Peter Bevan Executive Producer Jamie Jessop Executive Producer Mariana Sanjurjo Executive Producer Tomás Yankelevich Executive Producer Andrea Scarso Executive Producer Peter Mosiman Cinematographer Nicholas Wenger Film Editing Abbie Martin Costume Design Claire Koonce Casting Charlene Lee Casting