Rupert Wyatt Director John Goodman William Mulligan Actor Ashton Sanders Gabriel Drummond Actor Jonathan Majors Rafe Drummond Actor Vera Farmiga Jane Doe Actor Kevin Dunn Commissioner Eugene Igoe Actor James Ransone Patrick Ellison Actor Alan Ruck Charles Rittenhouse Actor Madeline Brewer Rula Actor Machine Gun Kelly Jurgis Actor Kevin J. O'Connor Kermode Actor Ben Daniels Daniel Actor KiKi Layne Carrie Actor D.B. Sweeney Levitt Actor Erica Beeney Screenwriter David Crockett Producer Jeff Skoll Executive Producer Jonathan King Executive Producer Ron Schmidt Executive Producer Adam Simon Executive Producer Alex Disenhof Cinematographer Andrew Groves Film Editing Rob Simonsen Original Music Keith P. Cunningham Production Design Abby O'Sullivan Costume Design Sheila Jaffe Casting Joan Philo Casting