Jennifer Kaytin Robinson Director, Screenwriter, Writer, Executive Producer Madelyn Cline Danica Richards Actor Chase Sui Wonders Ava Brucks Actor Jonah Hauer-King Milo Griffin Actor Tyriq Withers Teddy Spencer Actor Sarah Pidgeon Stevie Ward Actor Billy Campbell Grant Spencer Actor Gabbriette Bechtel Tyler Actor Austin Nichols Pastor Judah Actor Freddie Prinze Jr. Ray Bronson Actor Jennifer Love Hewitt Julie James Actor Sarah Michelle Gellar Helen Shivers Actor Brandy Norwood Karla Wilson Actor Nick Farnell Chief Roberts Actor Joshua Orpin Wyatt Actor Georgia Flood Hannah Decker Actor Nick Hardcastle Neal Actor Simone Annan Jill Spencer Actor Luke Van Os Officer Johnson Actor Isaiah Mustafa Andrew Actor Leah McKendrick Newscaster Actor, Writer Todd Giebenhain Jason Actor Brian Duffy Groundskeeper Actor Dalia Rooni Courtney Actor Sam Lansky Screenwriter Neal H. Moritz Producer Jackie Shenoo Executive Producer Karina Rahardja Executive Producer Elisha Christian Cinematographer Saira Haider Film Editing Chanda Dancy Original Music Courtney Andujar Production Design Hillary Andujar Production Design Loretta Cosgrove Art Director Lisa Brennan Set Decoration Mari-An Ceo Costume Design Ashley Marks Casting Lois Duncan Writer Matt Gustafson Associate Producer Virginia Berg Art Director Julia Altschul Set Decoration Kelly Fallon Set Decoration