Eli Craig Director, Screenwriter Adam Scott Gary Actor Evangeline Lilly Samantha Actor Donald Faison Larry Actor Bridget Everett AL Actor Clancy Brown Reverend Gospel Actor Tyler Labine Karl C. Miller Actor Chris D'Elia Wayne Actor Kyle Bornheimer Victor Actor Owen Atlas Lucas Actor Jason Michael Berman Producer Nicholas David Nesbitt Producer Ian Bricke Executive Producer Dylan Clark Executive Producer Mark Moran Executive Producer Scott Stuber Executive Producer Matthew Clark Cinematographer Tia Nolan Film Editing Marco Beltrami Original Music Brandon Roberts Original Music Marcus Trumpp Original Music Maher Ahmad Production Design Jim Warren Set Decoration Lynn Falconer Costume Design Angela Boehm Casting Mary Vernieu Casting Michelle Wade Byrd Casting