Martin Eden

Audience Reviews

View More

Alec B @Alec97 01/10/2024 I have a feeling this is less profound of an adaptation than the filmmakers think, that said I do appreciate the performances and the ending. See more Jon T @jon_talbot56 11/03/2023 This is a curiosity: I cannot really understand why people keep remaking this. The book is an exploration of the proto fascist ideas of Herbert Spencer who attempted to apply the survival of the fittest to human society. The eponymous hero is physically and mentally powerful so that he can flourish in a tough working class environment and conquers bourgeois society. He is a Spencerian Superman but it brings no fulfillment. All a bit weird if you ask me. The film feels disjointed and the underlying themes outdated. We have social security now for heavens sake. See more isla s @RT89656869 09/03/2022 This is a thoughtful watch - I was concerned it may be a bit too Les Miserables-esque, a film focussing purely on the pain of those far down the 'pecking order', which is the case in one respect but I actually thought this came across as a more hopeful film than I think I'd expected. Yes its about fighting against the opressive government/society/employers etc. 'the system' but its also a romance story and a story about a writer trying to find his feet (and his voice). The script is decent and I thought it was quite a gripping watch really. Yes, I would recommend this film, though its perhaps a bit of a challenging watch thematically but its certainly not entirely the gloom and doom I somehow imagined it to be (maybe I'm wearing rose tinted spectacles?). I also thought that Luca Marinelli gave a very good performance as the titular character. See more 04/18/2022 excellent italian reinterpretation of jack london See more wayne m @Wayne93 01/31/2022 Martin Eden is an ambitious, vibrant and bold film about a magnetic personality undergoing a journey of life. Based on the 1909 novel by Jack London this superb film has been moved to Naples, Italy. It's hard to pinpoint which era though as the technology changes through out the film. Eden is a sailor living a roustabout life with little education. He rescues a young man at the docks and is taken home to his family, the Orsinis. The Orsinis live a rich life of wealth and art and science. Eden falls in love with their daughter, Elena, and also vows to make himself educated and become a writer. The journey is a fruitful one and a long one. It's engaging and triumphant. The film is a heady mix of sex, politics and high idealism. All of which is anchored by a magnetic performance by Luca Marinelli. A film of high ambition and firm ideas. See more 08/18/2021 Based on Jack London's 1909 novel of the same name, Pietro Marcello's adaptation transposes the location of the story from California to Naples to stunning effect. Early on, Martin, who lives with his sister and her husband and their young children, rescues Arturo from a beating on a Napoli pier. So grateful is Arturo, he insists on bringing Martin to his family home so they can thank him in person. This is where Martin meets Elena, Arturo's sister, and falls hopelessly in love with her. It's a tale as old as time and indeed the novel on which it is based is over a century old. The cultured and refined Elena is not only the beacon to which Martin looks to romantically, it's her social status and class that Martin sets his heart on. As someone born into poverty, he's not had the same opportunities that Elena and her family have, and he aspires to reach her intellectual level at great cost and constant obstacles. Despite the problems posed by society and social structures, Martin is determined to be successful, and we are drawn into his quest with some truly superb acting by Luca Marinelli (who should draw awards attention with this performance) as well as his peers. We are given fascinating snippets of both Martin's earlier life and contextualised old stock film footage in frequent edits that give the film a haunting beauty, a feeling that never leaves, especially in its more tragic moments. Martin Eden is perfectly paced, merging the criteria of both a romantic drama and a something like a biopic to wonderful effect. It takes a an excellent romance film to fully draw me in, but the screenplay combined with the acting leave you no choice. Martin is no stranger to frollicking; his social class and upbringing doesn't leave much option for celibacy, but when he and Elena finally declare their love for each other, it's clear that it's something neither of them have experienced before. "I've never loved before," says a breathless Elena. "Let's learn together," replies Martin, in just one of a dozen achingly beautiful sequences. The film takes a political turn in the final third, brilliantly whipping up conflict between the pair as Martin turns to socialist circles to try and understand and impact his own world more effectively, and this brings him into dissension with Elena; right at a time that it seems Martin's dream to be a writer could have some traction. I urge you to seek it out. See more Read all reviews

Martin Eden

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING