The Annihilation of Fish

Critics Consensus

No consensus yet.

67%

TOMATOMETER

Total Count: 9

Coming soon

Release date: Jul 28, 2000

Audience Score

Ratings: Not yet available

Super Reviewer

Movie Info

Charles Burnett directed this offbeat comic romance about a pair of aging eccentrics whose imaginary companions sometimes interfere with their "real" lives. Fish (James Earl Jones) is an elderly Jamaican expatriate who has spend much of his adult life in a mental institution in New York. One of the clearest manifestations of Fish's madness is Hank, an imaginary nemesis whom Fish must often beat until he obeys. After he's released, Fish heads to Los Angeles, where he takes a room in a boarding house run by Mrs. Muldroone (Margot Kidder). Living across the hall from Fish is Poinsetta (Lynn Redgrave), an older woman who may be crazier than Fish: she drinks a great deal, loves to listen to Puccini, and is convinced that the long-dead composer is following her around (and is in love with her). In time, Fish and Poinsetta become friends and then lovers, but when she accidentally "kills" Hank, Fish is suddenly robbed of one of the only constants in his life. The Annihilation of Fish was screened in the 1999 Toronto Film Festival.

Rating:

R (for some sexual content)
Genre:

Comedy, Drama, Romance
Directed By:

Charles Burnett
Written By:

Anthony C. Winkler
In Theaters:

Jul 28, 2000 limited
Runtime:

108 minutes
Studio:

Regent Releasing

Cast

Margot Kidder
as Mrs. Muldroone

Lynn Redgrave
as Poinsetta

James Earl Jones
as Fish

Critic Reviews for The Annihilation of Fish

All Critics (9) | Top Critics (1)

[Burnett] creates a dreamily solid world where in Jones' heroic sweetness can flourish, and Redgrave and Kidder can disappear into their roles with a dazzling, playful intensity.

Nov 2, 2001

F.X. Feeney
L.A. Weekly
Top Critic
It's a small, graceful movie, and one of the beauties of it is imagining moviegoers tromping into Minneapolis' Parkway Theater to see it and -- for a couple of hours, at least -- forgetting their own feelings of loneliness.

Sep 19, 2003

Chris Hewitt
St. Paul Pioneer Press
Burnett has crafted a poignant, utterly believable film out of the most unlikely of set-ups.

Dec 8, 2002 | Rating: 4/5 | Full Review…

Merle Bertrand
Film Threat
Stuffed to the gills with kookiness, this Fish tanks.

Nov 9, 2001 | Full Review…

E! Staff
E! Online
What's Right: Nice performances from Redgrave and Jones.

Nov 1, 2001 | Full Review…

Dave White
IFilm
There are few comic staples less convincing or more timeworn than charming lunatics in love, and the only thing that lifts this film beyond TV-movie quality is Jones' performance.

Nov 1, 2001

Andy Klein
New Times
A guaranteed crowd-pleaser, no doubt due to the fine performances from Jones (other than his poor accent) and Redgrave.

Sep 18, 2001

Jon Popick
Planet S Magazine