Joe Mantegna David Rossi Actor Paget Brewster Emily Prentiss Actor Matthew Gray Gubler Dr. Spencer Reid Actor A.J. Cook Jennifer Jareau Actor Aisha Tyler Dr. Tara Lewis Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor Adam Rodriguez Luke Alvez Actor Daniel Henney Matt Simmons Actor Steven Grayhm Jess Carney (Unsub) Guest Star Jessi Fisher Wanda Robbins Guest Star John Tyler Vogt Larry Robbins Guest Star Lou Diamond Phillips Sheriff Clifford Guest Star Brad Hunt Casey Peters Guest Star Shannon Merrill Brown Timothy Kane Guest Star Jason Her Walter Knight Guest Star Carter Hastings Young Leland Peters Guest Star Connor Falk Young Jess Carney Guest Star Jason Trevits Mr. Kane Guest Star Christina Gentry Mrs. Kane Guest Star Preston Fladd Smitty Guest Star Mark Gordon Executive Producer Erica Messer Executive Producer Breen Frazier Executive Producer