Brandon Micheal Hall Miles Finer Actor Violett Beane Cara Bloom Actor Joe Morton Reverend Arthur Finer Actor Suraj Sharma Rakesh Singh Actor Javicia Leslie Ali Finer Actor Erica Gimpel Trish Actor Adam Goldberg Simon Hayes Guest Star Jessica Lu Joy Guest Star Susan Misner Annie Guest Star Bryan Greenberg Teddy Preston Guest Star Sawyer Barth Jacob Guest Star Zach Grenier James Abbott Guest Star Kaliswa Brewster Kathy Guest Star Peppermint Pastor Olivia Guest Star Marcel Simoneau Restaurant Manager Guest Star Steven Lilien Executive Producer Bryan Wynbrandt Executive Producer Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer Robert Hull Writer Darren Grant Director