John Rogers Creator, Executive Producer Chris Downey Creator, Executive Producer Timothy Hutton Nathan Ford Actor Gina Bellman Sophie Devereaux Actor Christian Kane Eliot Spencer Actor Beth Riesgraf Parker Actor Aldis Hodge Alec Hardison Actor Michael McGrady Sheriff Hastings Guest Star Mark Doerr Derrick Clark Guest Star Devon Graye Michael Clark Guest Star Rick Overton Taggert Guest Star Gerald Downey McSweeten Guest Star John Rezig Deputy Arnold Guest Star Lou Mulford Ellen Clark Guest Star Michael O'Neill Judge Roy Guest Star Mike Lutgen Meth Dealer Guest Star C.J. Bau Security Guard Guest Star Ezra Buzzington Frank Guest Star Megan Kathleen Duffy Young Teller Guest Star Dean Devlin Executive Producer, Director Amy Berg Writer