Ian Brennan Creator Ella Beatty Lizzie Borden Actor Vicky Krieps Bridget Sullivan Actor Charlie Hunnam Andrew Borden Actor Rebecca Hall Abby Borden Actor Billie Lourd Emma Borden Actor Jessica Barden Nance O'Neil Actor Joey Pollari Actor Sarah Paulson Actor Buddy Matthews Executive Producer Max Winkler Executive Producer Eric Kovtun Executive Producer Scott Robertson Executive Producer Louise Shore Executive Producer Nissa Diederich Executive Producer Todd Kubrak Executive Producer Carl Franklin Executive Producer Tanase Popa Executive Producer