Brothers (2009) - Rotten Tomatoes

Brothers (2009)



Critic Consensus: It plays more like a traditional melodrama than the Susanne Bier film that inspired it, but Jim Sheridan's Brothers benefits from rock-solid performances by its three leads.

Movie Info

Jim Sheridan's film, adapted from Susanne Bier's 2004 movie, concerns Captain Sam Cahill (Tobey Maguire), a Marine who receives orders to ship out for yet another tour of duty in Afghanistan. But before he leaves his supportive wife, Grace (Natalie Portman), and his two elementary-school-age daughters, Sam picks up his black sheep brother, Tommy (Jake Gyllenhaal), who has finished a prison stretch for robbing a bank. While overseas, Sam's aircraft gets shot down and he's thought dead. Back home, irresponsible Tommy gets his act together in order to be an anchor for Grace and the girls, and the two grow emotionally -- though not physically -- close. As the family finally begins to make peace with their grief, soldiers rescue POW Sam and he returns home. Sam's experiences overseas have caused him such emotional turmoil, he has a difficult time adjusting to civilian life, and soon his fear and paranoia manifest themselves in the form of jealousy for his brother's relationship with his wife. Sam Shepard and Mare Winningham co-star as the brothers' father and stepmother. ~ Perry Seibert, Rovimore
Rating: R (for language and some disturbing violent content)
Genre: Mystery & Suspense, Drama
Directed By:
Written By: David Benioff
In Theaters:
On DVD: Mar 23, 2010
Box Office: $28.5M
Lionsgate Films - Official Site


Tobey Maguire
as Capt. Sam Cahill
Jake Gyllenhaal
as Tommy Cahill
Natalie Portman
as Grace Cahill
Sam Shepard
as Hank Cahill
Mare Winningham
as Elsie Cahill
Clifton Collins Jr.
as Major Cavazos
Bailee Madison
as Isabelle Cahill
Taylor Geare
as Maggie Cahill
Patrick Flueger
as Private Joe Willis
Carey Mulligan
as Cassie Willis
Ethan Suplee
as Sweeney
Rebekah Wiggins
as Marine Wife
Carrie Fleming
as Marine Wife #2
Chad Brummett
as Co-Pilot
Jason R. Lone Hill
as Lt. Sanderson
Kevin Wiggins
as Navy Chaplain
Yusef Azami
as Taliban Leader
Yousuf Azami
as Taliban Leader
James Dever
as Sgt. Major Dever
Kevin Adkins
as Flag Detail Commande...
Richard Wade
as Crew Chief
Luce Rains
as The Nose
Paul Ramos
as Sentry
Shawn Bryan
as Marine Cadence
Oscar Meija
as Uniform in Helicopte...
Oscar Mejia
as Uniform in Helicopte...
David Bachelor
as U.S. Navy Chaplain
Zachary Grand
as Afghanistan Boy
Michael Aragon
as Terrorist
Iris Dunbar
as Burka Woman
Justin Marmion
as Marine Hostage
Robert Mitchell
as Marine Resucer #1
Collin D. Barry
as Marine Rescuer #2
Janet Sanford
as Mourner at Church #1
Casey Sanford
as Mourner at Church #2
Gary Moore
as Marine Mourner #1
Eric Steinig
as Marine Mourner #2
Colleen Frye
as Woman in Church
James Duffy
as Man in Church
David Manzanares
as Bartender "Dave"
Michael Castellano
as Afghan Fighter
Carol A. Salazar
as Woman on Bridge
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Brothers

Critic Reviews for Brothers

All Critics (151) | Top Critics (41)

It takes two-thirds of the film for any scene of real emotional truth or power to emerge - and by then we're lost.

Full Review… | January 22, 2010
Time Out
Top Critic

Anyone fond of Danish director Susanne Bier's 2004 original should steer clear of this ill-advised though faithful remake by Jim Sheridan.

Full Review… | September 24, 2014
Film Comment Magazine

A gritty sibling saga offers a strong reinforcement of the reality that, for many returned soldiers, some battle scars never heal.

Full Review… | September 30, 2011
American Profile

Well-acted war drama is too intense for kids.

Full Review… | December 31, 2010
Common Sense Media

Brothers is that rare type of film; one that feels real and true, never forcing itself to conform to the expectations of what a movie should contain.

Full Review… | October 21, 2010

Tobey Maguire's jaw seems squarer, his eyes electrified and - as Sam's features harden - like Robert De Niro circa "The Deer Hunter." When Sam snaps - all snarls, snot and spit - Maguire and Jim Sheridan place you in his percussive, throbbing psyche.

Full Review… | September 25, 2010

Audience Reviews for Brothers

I can't even imagine being Sam Cahill and going through what he did. This is a powerful movie and necessarily is left unfinished.

Red Lats

Super Reviewer

Sam Cahill: You know what I did to get back to you? You know what I did? 

"There are two sides to every family"

I've seen Brothers twice now, and my love for it went down a little on the second watch. I noticed a few scenes that were overplayed and badly written. Still, this is a really good drama and anti-war film. It shows the effects of war on a man and how he struggles coming back to normal everyday life. There's good character development at the beginning with Sam. We see how much he loves his family and how happy he is around them. That makes his lack of openness when he comes back have a little more power. The film is powerful despite the melodrama. This is one of the few films I've seen where the melodrama doesn't take away from the power of the situation. 

The film is about a man who goes to Afghanistan and is supposedly killed. In reality, he is a prisoner of war who goes through unspeakable things. Back in America, his family is comforted by his brother. When he comes back he isn't the same man, and he also has some accusations to throw around about his brother and wife's relationship. The story is really interesting and drove by good performances from Tobey Maguire, Jake Gyllenhaal, and Natalie Portman. Portman gave one of the best performances here, up to that point in her career. There's something about her that makes her seem very real, and allows her to nail this performance with a great deal of believability. 

This has been criticized a lot for being overly melodramatic. I can't say that it isn't either, but I never felt the melodrama rose to a level that hurt the film. There's a lot of screaming, crying, and smashing, but the story is emotional and so are the characters. Are some scenes overwritten for a tearjerking effect? Yeah. Still, I don't think the overall power of the film was hurt by the melodrama, but that is just my opinion on the matter. That's also coming from someone who normally hates melodrama. This is one of those rare occasions where it didn't ruin a film for me.

It isn't going to win any subtlety contests, but based on the central performances and the sheer power of the story and how the events unfold before our eyes; I think it is good. Good actors doing good work in a film that is worthy of the performances. I can't say the movie is perfect, but overall it works and gets the point across.

Melvin White

Super Reviewer

An incredibly well-acted movie. Toby Maguire, Natalie Portman, and Jake Gyllenhaal were all terrific. They took a cheesy, weak screenplay and made it believable and interesting. However, the movie suffers from overly simplistic pacing, cliche plot, and a lack of depth in the plot. Once again, great acting. It is good to note that though this movie has many many flaws, there is character development that genuinely gets us invested.

Albert Kim
Albert Kim

Super Reviewer

Brothers Quotes

– Submitted by Baurushan J (2 years ago)
– Submitted by Baurushan J (2 years ago)

Discussion Forum

Discuss Brothers on our Movie forum!