Going My Way (1944) - Rotten Tomatoes

Going My Way (1944)



Critic Consensus: Bing Crosby and Barry Fitzgerald are eminently likable, and film is pleasantly sentimental, but Going My Way suffers from a surplus of sweetness.

Movie Info

It took some doing to persuade the staunchly Catholic Bing Crosby to play a happy-go-lucky priest in Going My Way; luckily he acquiesced, winning an Academy Award in the process. Crosby is cast as Father Chuck O'Malley, newly arrived at rundown, heavily in debt St. Dominic's Church. Father Fitzgibbon (Barry Fitzgerald), the cranky, set-in-his-ways curate of St. Dominic's, is none too pleased with O'Malley's breezy, "modernistic" methods. Fitzgibbon is content to adhere to the policies he has followed for nearly 45 years. Without overtly challenging Fitzgibbon's authority (he likes the old buzzard, and the feeling is mutual), O'Malley sets about to win the confidence of the local street toughs, organizing the boys into an angelic church choir. He also forestalls the plans of St. Dominic's mortgage holder Ted Haines (Gene Lockhart) to evict Fitzgibbons by arranging a fundraising choir tour, to be headlined by O'Malley's childhood friend, opera star Genevieve Linden (Rise Stevens). When he's not coming to the rescue of St. Dominic's, O'Malley is smoothing the path of romance for Haines' son (James Brown) and orphaned Carol James (Jean Heather), and arranging for a reunion between Fitzgibbons and his nonagenarian Irish mother. There is sentiment by the bucketful in Going My Way, but director Leo McCarey sagaciously tempers the treacle with moments of genuine hilarity and several delightful (and seemingly spontaneous) musical interludes. In addition to Crosby, Oscars went to Barry Fitzgerald, Leo McCarey, screenwriters Frank Butler and Frank Cavett, and Burke and Van Heusen's song hit "Swingin' On a Star." Bing Crosby repeated his father O'Malley characterization in McCarey's 1945 sequel The Bells of St. Mary's. ~ Hal Erickson, Rovimore
Rating: G
Genre: Drama, Musical & Performing Arts, Classics, Comedy
Directed By:
Written By: Frank Corvett, Frank Butler, Frank Cavett, Frank R. Butler, Leo McCarey
In Theaters:
On DVD: Feb 6, 2007
Paramount Pictures


Bing Crosby
as Father O'Malley
Barry Fitzgerald
as Father Fitzgibbon
Eily Malyon
as Mrs. Carmody
Porter Hall
as Belknap
Thomas P. Dillon
as Officer McCarthy
George Nokes
as Pee Wee
Tom Dillon
as McCarthy
Hugh Maguire
as Pitch Pipe
Sybil Lewis
as Maid at Metropolitan...
George McKay
as Mr. Van Heusen
Jack Norton
as Mr. Lilley
Anita Bolster
as Mrs. Quimp
Adeline de Walt Reyn...
as Mother Fitzgibbon
Gibson Gowland
as Churchgoer
Julie Gibson
as Taxi Driver
Robert Tafur
as Don Jose
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for Going My Way

Critic Reviews for Going My Way

All Critics (23) | Top Critics (6)

Paramount may have made a more appealing, more tenderly human and amusing picture than "Going My Way," during its many years of film-making, but if so, I have missed it.

Full Review… | February 17, 2015
New York Daily News
Top Critic

There's nothing special or memorable about this overlong endeavor, the first of two motion pictures to feature Bing Crosby's insufferably noble Father Chuck O'Malley.

Full Review… | August 31, 2010
Top Critic

It offers, in the performance of nutcracker-faced, 56-year-old Barry Fitzgerald, the finest, funniest and most touching portrayal of old age that has yet reached the screen.

Full Review… | February 17, 2009
TIME Magazine
Top Critic

Major thread of gaiety runs through the proceedings, and McCarey has liberally sprinkled sparkling individual episodes along the way for cinch audience reaction.

Full Review… | January 28, 2008
Top Critic

Go anywhere to avoid it.

Full Review… | February 9, 2006
Time Out
Top Critic

Rich, warm and human to the core.

Full Review… | May 20, 2003
New York Times
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for Going My Way

Alright, so yeah, this film is very old fashioned, schmaltzy, sentimental, and even a tad corny perhaps, but you know what? I don't care. It's entertaining, well meaning, pretty good, and really hard not to like. We need stuff like this once in a while.

The story concerns a young and easy going priest named Chuck O'Malley who is assigned to St. Dominic's: a church on the brink of going under. He doesn't get along with the head priest Father Fitzgibbon, but when the effects of O'Malley's attempts to bring the community together are felt, things do begin to change for the better.

This is a nice little film, and it did spawn a sequel: The Bells of St. Mary's. That one's a lot like this one, with a similar plot and premise, but it is here where Crosby originated the character, and won an Oscar for his efforts. He really does put in some nice work, and he, like the character, is just really hard to dislike. He's just so damn charming and irresistable I can't stand it.

Barry Fitzgerald is also quite good as Fitzgibbon. and Rise Stevens and Frank McHugh are decent as childhood friends of O'Malley's.

All in all, this may be a pretty light and predictable film, but it's a harmless film with a lot of heart and a good message. It also looks good, and the singing is top notch too. Give this one a go. It may not be worthy of all of the Oscars it won, but it's hardly a forgettable piece of dreck.

Chris Weber

Super Reviewer

An unconventional priest works to reform a failing parish.
I'm a big fan of Bing Crosby's voice; so easy and melodic, he makes it seem as though anyone can sing like him, which of course no one can. But this isn't a musical. It isn't a drama or comedy either. If anything, it's two hours of the most saccharine nonsense I've seen. At the heart of this diabetic's nightmare is Crosby's character, Father O'Malley, who is flawless. His character is never put up for question, and his methods, ideals, mannerisms, or personality remain thoroughly unchallenged by other characters, the film's circumstances, or any subjectivity. He is just there in an untarnished and idolized unreality. The film's problems, such as they are, seem no match for O'Malley, and we see him easily navigate the church's financial troubles, a woman who's run away from home, and an old flame who serendipitously re-enters his life. And when the film ends on another sweet note, I felt like I had just seen a slice of life that was so watered down with religious idealism that it bore no resemblance to anything I've seen living.
Overall, there's nothing memorable about Going My Way except for the few moments when we get to hear Crosby sing, but for that you can buy the soundtrack and save yourself two hours.

Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer


Crosby plays a young cool priest who helps out the community and the parish. A really nice movie, I couldn't help but like it.

Aj V

Super Reviewer

Going My Way Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

Discussion Forum

Discuss Going My Way on our Movie forum!