Oblivion Reviews
Super Reviewer
The special effects are well-done, especially when it comes to the mechanical elements like the intimidating drones, which move with both a weightiness and agility that combines to form something you would definitely not want to meet in a dark alley, and Tom Cruise's ship is a really imaginative piece of futuristic technology as well. M83's score is a mixed bag. Choosing this band for this movie is the absolute perfect choice, as they have that epic, desolate futuristic-yet-retro feel to them to begin with. Unfortunately, the score they have composed rarely sounds like their 'actual' music as much as it does an imitation of contemporary blockbuster scores. Had they gone their own route (or used some tracks from their discography), they could have came up with something that really made 'Oblivion' stand out from the pack. This is just an example of the larger problem with 'Oblivion': it isn't a bad movie, but in every instance where it has a chance to be a pioneer and do something fresh, it falls back on the crutches of the past, and ends up feeling rather generic as a result.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
But frankly, I really enjoyed the last few closing acts before the film ended. There were a lot of key moments that really stood out, filling my love for Sci Fi themes. (Discovering he's a clone and dealing with it, Jack not telling the 2nd Victoria the truth, Jack bringing Malcom rather than Julia etc.)
A lot of critics argue a lack of emotion or that characters are forgotten as soon as the "action" rolls in but that may be because all the players seem like characters in a Victorian play and never really "alive" in the first place.
Finally, let's not forget the top notch visuals. The Scifi concept art team behind this movie did a really wonderful job with the overall designs and as an artist myself, I can't help but appreciate it all.
It's definitely no Minority Report and it's rare for a movie to start off horrible and then get better (as opposed to having a strong start and progressively get worse) but if you love Sci Fi I think it's a pretty enjoyable experience that uses it's tropes effectively more so than falling victim to them.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
It is hard to create anything truly original these days and it is ok to borrow some elements to your films, but the way Kosinki uses Moon's ideas is just cheap and arrogant. It is like he thought that no one saw that great film all. Moon may not be even remotely as massive or popular as a film but it still light years more clever and better nuanced than Oblivion can even dream of. I am not saying that Kosinki does not have talent. The way he handles the action scenes is quite impressive and he seems to know how to put on a great show when it comes to effects and visuals. But there lies the major problem of this filmmaker. He is one of those artists who is much more interested of the surface than the emotions. He clearly tries get a emotional impact from his audience but there is not a moment in this film where he could actually make us care these cold and distant characters.
What Oblivion is missing is mostly a heart. As i said it is wonderful film to look at and Claudio Miranda's camerawork is often impressive. Still, to be honest good visuals and camerawork does not make a good film and hopefully next time when Kosinki makes a film he also remembers to create characters that we actually care for. Oblivion is a awfully polished and hollow piece of science fiction that is lacking a soul.
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
If you've been keeping up with sci-fi cinema in the last couple decades, you'll likely recognize more than a few elements with Oblivion. From its themes to its plot points to its revelations, there's little here to designate as original. So the real question remains how derivative can we take? I think when the execution is nimble then it's one of the easiest sins to remember. Especially in the realm of sci-fi cinema, it's hard to put together a new story, let alone one set up as a Hollywood star vehicle, without borrowing from other established movies. This in itself is not an issue. Tarantino is a master borrower but he always recontextualizes his artistic influences into something new and different, and while we critics lament his less original career path of late, the man's box-office profits have never been better in his career. I think when we feel like we're getting a good story we don't care when that story has been told before in other manners. Star Wars, after all, has many cultural fathers, but it was a rollicking good time with characters we cared about, so nobody seemed to mind. Likewise, Oblivion has many forbearers from Independence Day to I Am Legend to 2001 to an indie film from a few years ago I shall refrain from mentioning because even the very mention will spoil key plot points. Some will decry the film as a rip-off of superior, headier fare, but I never minded. I was having too good of a time and found the movie too satisfying to quibble.
I won't say the movie is smart per se but it's far more measured than I would have expected. The advertising makes it look like Cruise fights a bunch of aliens and robots, and while there is that aspect, it's almost an afterthought to a slow-burning mystery that patiently parcels out its revelations, even to the very end of the film. I'm trying to be cagey about certain plot points to avoid spoilers. It's a film that has more on its mind than explosions, but when it goes into explosion mode, director Joseph Kosinski (TRON: Legacy) makes it count. The larger action elements are well staged and polished with some above average special effects. The sight of the moon dashed across the sky is definitely an evocative image. I love the overall look of the film, Kosinki's clean, spare, bubbly Apple-esque aesthetics. The drones themselves manage to have personality even with a limited, streamlined design and some choice sound design. The man knows how to hold onto an image and when to keep pushing. The action is suitably thrilling and the drama suitably suspenseful. Actually, better than suitably. I enjoyed the details of this world. It's probably the spiffiest post-apocalyptic landscape you'll ever see. This is an entertaining movie that finds nice ways to satisfy, and given the particulars of its sci-fi plot, finds a way to have its cake and eat it too. As a result, Oblivion is a sci-fi flick that offers enough to engage the mind and audience demands for big effects and big thrills.
I've never been a Cruise hater. I even thought the man tried his damndest to make a movie like Rock of Ages worth watching (a valiant effort but not enough). His character is pretty affable at first and we get to watch as everything he knows comes undone. It's a role that would lead to overacting, but Cruise underplays the part, more alarmed naïf than flinty action hero. I'm not expecting Oscar-caliber performances in every role but Cruise does a fine job of anchoring the audience and selling his character's journey. He also has good chemistry with not one but two ladies. Kurylenko (Seven Psychopaths, To the Wonder) is an actress of great beauty and questionable talent, but perhaps being paired up with a genuine star like Cruise brings out the best in her. They're good together, though my preference was for Riseborough (W.E., Never Let Me Go), an actress who brings a tremulous vulnerability to an otherwise underwritten and confused character that's more a plot device. Riseborough makes the character so much more than she is on the page. She's still a relatively new actress so I look forward to her future performances. There are other familiar faces, like Morgan Freeman and an especially unsettling Melissa Leo, but it's really a three-person acting exercise.
Oblivion is a visually alluring sci-fi thriller that also manages to have enough heart and smarts to leave a satisfying impression. The pacing is more deliberate but offers plenty rewards, doling out revelations up until the end, unpacking its mystery with finesse. The first twenty minutes or so, establishing the particulars of this world and the routine of our protagonists, is downright exceptional. The rest of the film doesn't quite live up to that start but it continues to be an engaging and entertaining movie with some top-notch visuals. The musical score by electronic band M83 also provides a stirring counterpoint to the glossy, clean visuals (the band's song "Outro" was also very effectively used in that lovely five-minute trailer for Cloud Atlas). You may figure things out as you watch, but you won't mind, at least I didn't. The more I step away the more I think back with renewed enthusiasm for the film. It's smarter, slicker, and just a more satisfying film than we're accustomed to with this kind of budget and from Hollywood.
Nate's Grade: B
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Super Reviewer
Normally this would work against my enjoyment of the film, since Oblivion doesn't have an original thought in its head. Strangely enough, it's not always about the story being told; it's how it's being told and in this respect, Oblivion still feels fresh and unique. The visuals are absolutely stunning, the story is fascinating, the soundtrack is awesome, and every performer is at the top of his or her game. Cinema history may not recognize Oblivion as an example of great sci-fi, but just as some people defend James Cameron's Avatar to no end, I submit that Oblivion is damn fine entertainment, a much more satisfying experience than I expected it to be.
Super Reviewer
Excellent Film!. Here's a fine example of a film that may have an inconsistent and a familiar screenplay, but still makes up for an exciting watch due to its director Joseph Kosinski's extra-ordinary sense of creating spectacles that feel like breathing artworks. Tom Cruise plays Tom Cruise but that's not a bad thing in this case, in fact his natural charisma carries the movie through some of its slower sections. Morgan Freeman plays Morgan Freeman though he's really not on screen for long enough to influence the movie one way or another. Olga Kurylenko's statuesque profile is unfortunately not matched by her acting ability and I often found it difficult to believe in her character's actions and emotions. Andrea Riseborough turns in maybe the best performance, convincing as the sad and confused Victoria, unwilling - or perhaps unable - to confront the disturbing truth. Overall, I would definitely recommend going to see this movie in the cinema, on the biggest screen that you can find. It just won't be the same on TV. The visual appeal alone is reason enough, but combined with a clever script, a thumping soundtrack and some exciting action, you should be entertained.
One of the few remaining drone repairmen assigned to Earth, its surface devastated after decades of war with the alien Scavs, discovers a crashed spacecraft with contents that bring into question everything he believed about the war, and may even put the fate of mankind in his hands.
