All Critics (200)
|
Top Critics (42)
|
Fresh (117)
|
Rotten (90)
|
DVD (17)
In the hands of a director more suited to the material The Soloist might have been a deeply moving experience. Here, we know something important is being played out before us, and there are times when it hits home with force. But in their exercise of dram
Has its moments, but too heavy-handed and predictable.
Tthis is a maudlin, stereotypical story that never moved at all.
The film's biggest problem lies really in its pacing. Every time the plot takes an interesting turn or moves forward, it's stalled by one musical montage after another.
I wish The Soloist had done more than pay lip service to this subject, but the traces of what might have been are still resonant.
A failed and problematic Oscar hopeful being dumped in theaters a week before the start of Hollywood's summer season.
The subject matter is a little too easy to overdo for that, but it is pretty good, thanks to a pair of fine performances from its leads and a director who understands understatement. And sometimes those can be as rare to find as a genuine musical prodigy.
The Soloist never completely transcends that Hollywood formula feel, but it has enough transcendent moments to make it worth recommending.
There's no crescendo in Joe Wright's drama.
While Downey and Foxx did fine jobs acting, the script they were handed was just so deliberately attempting to make the audience weep.
Develops the feel-good plot in true newspaper style: a few heart tugs followed by a punch in the face.
Una película sobre periodismo y marginalidad, sobre el poder redentor del arte y la solidaridad humana, sostenida por dos buenas actuaciones de Jamie Foxx y Robert Downey Jr.
The music's as troubled as the subject matter
"The Soloist" is not a film in which you anticipate Robert Downey Jr. will be twice doused in urine. Such are the territorial markings of Joe Wright, whose directorial quirks undermine moving moments and committed performances in this musical biopic.
The two actors work beautifully together, playing characters who are angry and frustrated in their different ways, and sentimentality is kept firmly at bay.
Intelligent and uncompromising, with knock-out performances from Downey Jr. and Foxx.
A deliriously imperfect film - and all the better for it.
The Soloist brings to life its story with genuine compassion, neatly avoiding many of the traps that afflict Hollywood films about mental illness. And Jamie Foxx's transformation will simply astound.
Ultimately, the reason that The Soloist fails is because the writer and the director have been bamboozled by the seriousness of the subject matter.
A handsomely made but tonally uncertain film; it's unsure whether to be an old-fashioned inspirational heartwarmer, or a paranoid prose-poem about ruined lives on the city's dangerous margins.
The Soloist has its imperfections, but its ambition trumps them.
More Critic Reviews
Top Critic
