Brian Crano Director, Screenwriter Jason Ritter Ben Actor Jake Sandvig Alan Actor, Screenwriter Chandler Canterbury Kelsey Actor Rebecca Hall Mel Actor Carrie Preston Lynette Actor Todd Louiso Marty Actor Gabriel Macht Wyatt Actor Amanda Seyfried Amanda Actor Erik Eidem Erik Actor Micah A. Hauptman Vince Actor Peter Friedlander Producer Lucy Barzun Donnelly Producer Jennifer Barrons Producer Byron Shah Cinematographer Quyen Tran Cinematographer Brian A. Kates Film Editing Travis Sittard Film Editing Johnny Flynn Original Music Bradley Thordarson Production Design Angela How Art Director Michelle Sandvig Costume Design Brad Gilmore Casting