Mary McCormack Mary Shannon Actor Frederick Weller Marshall Mann Actor Nichole Hiltz Brandi Shannon Actor Paul Ben-Victor Stan McQueen Actor Todd Williams Bobby D Actor Cristián de la Fuente Raphael Ramirez Actor Joshua Malina Peter Alpert Guest Star Martin Landau Joseph Thomas , Joseph Tancredi Guest Star Holly Maples Eleanor Prince Guest Star Andy Comeau Barry Ness Guest Star Hank Rogerson Tom Miller Guest Star Evan Bobrick Joseph Tancredi Guest Star Colin Jones New Reggie Guest Star Fran Martone Michelle Tancredi Guest Star J. Ryan Montenery Reggie (1970's) Guest Star Carmen Serano Director Brynn Malone Writer