Mark Feuerstein Actor Paulo Costanzo Actor Reshma Shetty Actor Jill Flint Actor Andrew McCarthy Marshall Bryant Guest Star Gillian Jacobs Tess Frimoli Guest Star Ezra Miller Tucker Bryant Guest Star Meredith Hagner Libby Guest Star Michael Mulheren Jim Harper Guest Star Christina Gausas Sheila Montgomery Guest Star Patrick Boll Seersucker Man Guest Star Victor Cruz Fisherman Guest Star Elijah Moreland Hampton's Renter Guest Star Orlando McDonald The Server Guest Star Pauline Chalamet Lead Ballerina Guest Star Joanna Janetakis Party girl Guest Star Nick Diamantis Waiter Guest Star Paul Weaver Garden Party Attendee Guest Star Rich Frank Executive Producer Paul Frank Executive Producer Jeff Kwatinetz Executive Producer