Tony Hale Mr. Benedict, Mr. Curtain Actor Kristen Schaal Number Two Actor MaameYaa Boafo Rhonda Actor Ryan Hurst Milligan Actor Gia Sandhu Ms. Perumal Actor Mystic Inscho Reynie Muldoon Actor Emmy Deoliveira Kate Weatherall Actor Seth Carr George "Sticky" Washington Actor Marta Kessler Constance Contraire Actor Karen Kehela Sherwood Executive Producer Deepak Nayar Executive Producer James Bobin Executive Producer Todd Slavkin Executive Producer Matt Manfredi Executive Producer Phil Hay Executive Producer Darren Swimmer Executive Producer David Ellender Executive Producer Jamie Tarses Executive Producer Matthew Loze Executive Producer