Colby Donaldson Host Adam Benson Contestant Alex Charvat Contestant Blake Miguez Contestant Brian Zins Contestant Chee Kwan Contestant Chris Cerino Contestant Gabby Franco Contestant Gary Quensenberry Contestant Greg Littlejohn Contestant Jamie Franks Contestant Joe Serafini Contestant Kelly Bachand Contestant Kyle Sumpter Contestant Peter Palma Contestant Phil Morden Contestant William Bethards Contestant Zachary Behr Executive Producer Wendy Greene Executive Producer Craig Piligian Executive Producer Ralph Wikke Executive Producer Mitch Rosa Executive Producer