Ben H. Winters Creator, Executive Producer Justin Hartley Colter Shaw Actor, Executive Producer Fiona Rene Reenie Actor Abby McEnany Velma Actor Eric Graise Bobby Actor Sofia Pernas Billie Matalon Guest Star Brent Sexton Keaton Guest Star Melissa Roxburgh Dory Shaw Guest Star Marci T. House Guest Star Michael Rady Elliot Guest Star Jensen Ackles Russell Shaw Actor Aliyah Brooks Amy Actor Jason McKinnon Lawyer Actor Dianna Maria Riva Detective Helen Brock Guest Star Pej Vahdat Leo Sharf Guest Star Ken Olin Executive Producer, Director Jeffrey Deaver Executive Producer Elwood Reid Executive Producer, Writer Sharon Lee Watson Writer Ryan O'Nan Writer Alex Katsnelson Writer Travis Donnelly Writer Annakate Chappell Writer Travis Donelly Writer Dominique A. Holmes Writer Dominique Holmes Writer Jai Franklin Sarki Writer Amanda Mortlock Writer Aprill Winney Director Douglas Aarniokoski Director