Sam Elliott Detective Lukas Black Actor Jamie Kennedy Albert Straka Actor Carlton Lynx Sara Carreni Actor Michael Cavalieri Frank Carreni Actor Lori Heuring Emily Actor Keith David Detective Charles Desett Actor Bridget Ellen Tina Actor Nick Swardson Shaun Actor Michael Philip Jim Actor Karen Bailey Marlene Actor Jonny Van Okur Wayne Actor Ruta Lee Antique Store Patron Actor Robert Harvey Detective Tableau Actor Aaron Zuber Psychotic Criminal Actor Archie Drury Walter Actor Peter Alias Sarah's Father Actor Al Faris Store Keeper Actor Elisa Benini Teenage Sarah Actor Gloria Gebbia Executive Producer John Gebbia Executive Producer Christopher Keller Executive Producer, Writer