Aneesh Chaganty Director, Screenwriter Sarah Paulson Diane Sherman Actor Kiera Allen Chloe Sherman Actor Onalee Ames Crying Hands Actor Pat Healy Ted Sherman Actor Carter Heintz Nivea Boy Actor Clark Webster Loser Actor Conan Hodgkinson Winner Actor Erik Athavale Doctor Actor Bradley Sawatzky Obstetrician Actor Sev Ohanian Screenwriter, Producer Natalie Qasabian Producer Hillary Spera Cinematographer Torin Borrowdale Original Music Jean-Andre Carriere Production Design Gary Barringer Art Director Sara McCudden Set Decoration Heather Neale Costume Design Rich Delia Casting