The Dutchman

Play trailer

The Dutchman

R

Jan 2026

1h 28m

Mystery & Thriller

Drama

Play Trailer

Watchlist

Watchlist

Tomatometer

Popcornmeter

59%

Tomatometer

39 Reviews

86%

Popcornmeter

250+ Ratings

Clay, a successful but troubled black businessman, attends therapy sessions with his wife, Kaya, in an attempt to salvage their marriage. But their mysterious therapist is not all that he seems, and begins to unexpectedly appear to Clay outside of their sessions. On a New York subway train, Clay encounters Lula, a seductive but sinister white stranger who slowly begins to unravel his life. Clay must discover the truth behind this encounter to get back to his wife, heal his fractured soul, and survive the night. In this modern adaptation of the 1964 Obie Award winning play, The Dutchman brings a contemporary edge to the original, exploring themes of race and identity in America.

Watch on Fandango at Home

Stream Now

Critics Consensus

Despite strong aesthetics and Andre Holland's richly textured performance, The Dutchman unfolds as a muddled reworking of the stage play that fails to find thematic coherence and a sense of identity.

Read Critics Reviews

Peter Travers

The Travers Take

Jan 9

3/4

In a fresh film take a 1964 race play, Kate Mara’s sexed-up subway rider hits on André Holland like a white Eve out to destroy a Black Adam through assimilation, intimidation, and worse. You can’t watch it passively. It dares you to engage.

Go to Full Review

Murtada Elfadl

Variety

Jan 6

The film adds modern references and takes place in the present, but its treatment of the play’s themes remains murky and marred by an inability to let go of what director Andre Gaines evidently considers to be a sacred text.

Go to Full Review

William Bibbiani

TheWrap

Jan 2

It’s easy to appreciate the ambition of Gaines’ new take on 'Dutchman,' but the original tale is fighting back, and it’s got the upper hand.

Go to Full Review

Laura Hiros

Rincón de cine

4d

4/5

(...) it is definitely a film worth watching with commitment, with complete attention—an excellent start to the cinematic year with thought-provoking films like this one. [Full Review in Spanish]

Go to Full Review

Lapacazo Magrira Sandoval

New York Amsterdam News

5d

The added material does not resolve the mystery of Dutchman so much as deepen its psychological stakes, shifting the focus from a single explosive encounter to the emotional and social conditions that make that explosion feel unavoidable.

Go to Full Review

Leo Brady

AMovieGuy.com

Jan 27

3/4

The Dutchman intrigues and unsettles, drawing the audience into a dark and dangerous dance with the devil.

Go to Full Review

Read all reviews

Juandi

15h

It’s always underwhelming & awkward when good actors can’t make up for a movie that’s lacking in many areas. It had potential to be a fun mind trip but instead ends up leaving you asking “I guess?”

See more

laurence k

Jan 8

New but still true to the original, The Dutchman ends up impressing on many levels. Terrific acting and music with cinematography that creates an unsettling, disturbing mood throughout. I feel like my audience all knew the original and we all applauded afterwards.

See more

Marie

Jan 7

This film would’ve been better in the theater rather than theatrical format. While it was short in length, it just felt drawn out to make it 90 minutes. I was alone in the theater and I understood why. There was very little if any marketing and it was boring, beautifully acted but boring for a movie.

See more

Phillip

Jan 6

I liked it. Shout out Black Love.

See more

Robert O

Jan 6

Movie should have been better. Needed more depth into the wife’s affair to start the movie to sympathize with the husband and the pain and betrayal he felt. And his affair needed to be much steamier if that was going to be a main focus.

See more

Norm V

Jan 5

Suspenseful but confusing plot and unclear ending.

See more

Read all reviews

Read More

Read Less

POST RATING

WRITE A REVIEW

EDIT REVIEW

Andre Gaines

Director

André Holland

Clay

Kate Mara

Lula

Stephen Henderson

Dr. Amiri

Zazie Beetz

Kaya

Aldis Hodge

Warren

7 Films (and 1 TV Series) We Can’t Wait to See at SXSW 2025

View more photos

Synopsis

Clay, a successful but troubled black businessman, attends therapy sessions with his wife, Kaya, in an attempt to salvage their marriage. But their mysterious therapist is not all that he seems, and begins to unexpectedly appear to Clay outside of their sessions. On a New York subway train, Clay encounters Lula, a seductive but sinister white stranger who slowly begins to unravel his life. Clay must discover the truth behind this encounter to get back to his wife, heal his fractured soul, and survive the night. In this modern adaptation of the 1964 Obie Award winning play, The Dutchman brings a contemporary edge to the original, exploring themes of race and identity in America.

Director: Andre Gaines
Producer: Andre Gaines, Jonathan Baker
Screenwriter: Qasim Basir, Andre Gaines
Distributor: Rogue Pictures / Inaugural Entertainment
Production Co: Federal Films, Cinemation Studios, Washingston Square Films
Rating: R (Brief Violence|Sexual Content|Language)
Genre: Mystery & Thriller, Drama
Original Language: English
Release Date (Theaters): Jan 2, 2026, Limited
Release Date (Streaming): Feb 3, 2026
Runtime: 1h 28m

Most Popular at Home Now