Jason Ritter Kevin Finn Actor JoAnna Garcia Swisher Amy Cabrera Actor Kimberly Hebert Gregory Yvette Actor Chloe East Reese Cabrera Actor J. August Richards Deputy Nate Purcell Actor Dustin Ybarra Tyler Medina Actor India de Beaufort Kristin Allen Actor Will Sasso Dave Guest Star Rhenzy Feliz Marc Guest Star Lesley Boone Lucille Russo Guest Star Bret Harrison Sam Guest Star Tyler Labine Sock Guest Star Michele Fazekas Executive Producer Tara Butters Executive Producer Chris Dingess Executive Producer, Writer Craig DiGregorio Executive Producer, Writer Michael Patrick Jann Director