The Cotton Club (1984)

TOMATOMETER

AUDIENCE SCORE

Critic Consensus: No consensus yet.

The Cotton Club Videos

The Cotton Club Photos

Movie Info

There are those who insist that the backstage intrigues which occurred during the production of Cotton Club would make a better film than Cotton Club itself. Essentially, this "dream" project of director Francis Ford Coppola was intended to reflect the passing parade of New York in the 1930s, using Harlem's famed Cotton Club nitery as a metaphor of the era. After innumerable in-progress script changes were made and countless post-production "improvements" were imposed, what emerged was a crazy quilt of varying styles, divergent acting techniques and stop-and-start plotlines. Occasionally, Cotton Club is well up to the standards established by Coppola in his earlier, more successful films. The central character, loosely based on George Raft and played by Richard Gere, is a jazz cornet player at the Cotton Club. Gere saves the life of gangster Dutch Schultz (James Remar), who in gratitude takes Gere under his wing, engaging the young man's services as escort for Schultz's girl friend Diane Lane (guess where this leads?) Meanwhile, Gere's overambitious hoodlum brother Nicolas Cage (playing a character inspired by mobster Mad Dog Coll) kills two innocent children during a mob hit and is forced to go into hiding. Cage holds gangster Frenchy Demarge (Fred Gwynne) as a hostage, but Demarge's safety is negotiated by Owney Madden (Bob Hoskins), the mob owner of the Cotton Club (the touching friendship between Demarge and Madden is one of the few subplots to remain intact in the film's release version). Cage is killed, followed in death shortly afterward by Schultz, who is put "on the spot" by Lucky Luciano (Joe Dallesandro). Gere wins a Hollywood movie contract and heads off to Tinseltown with Diane Lane. These plot convolutions tend to diminish the importance of the black characters who work as Cotton Club entertainers. The intriguing fact that blacks were permitted to perform at the club but were denied access as patrons should have been given as much emphasis as Richard Gere's story; instead, we are left with tantalizingly brief snatches of a romance between Gregory Hines and Lonette McKee, and a few scattered musical numbers involving Hines, his brother Maurice, Charles "Honi" Coles, and a staggeringly good Cab Calloway imitator (Larry T. Marshall). Cotton Club tends to leave the viewer feeling as though several vital ingredients are missing from the recipe, but there is still a lot left over to please the ear and eye.
Rating:
R (adult situations/language, violence)
Genre:
Drama , Musical & Performing Arts
Directed By:
Written By:
In Theaters:
 wide
On DVD:
Runtime:
Studio:
Nelson Entertainment

Watch it now

Cast

Richard Gere
as Dixie Dwyer
Gregory Hines
as Sandman Williams
Diane Lane
as Vera Cicero
Lonette McKee
as Lila Rose Oliver
James Remar
as Dutch Schultz
Nicolas Cage
as Vincent Dwyer
Allen Garfield
as Abbadabba Berman
Bob Hoskins
as Owney Madden
Fred Gwynne
as Frenchy Demange
Gwen Verdon
as Tish Dwyer
Lisa Jane Persky
as Frances Flegenheimer
Maurice Hines
as Clay Williams
Julian Beck
as Sol Weinstein
Novella Nelson
as Mme. St. Clair
Laurence Fishburne
as Bumpy Rhodes
Tom Waits
as Irving Stark
Ron Karabatsos
as Mike Best
Glen Witherow
as Ed Popke
Jennifer Grey
as Patsy Dwyer
Wynonna Smith
as Winnie Williams
Thelma Carpenter
as Norma Williams
Charles "Honi" Coles
as Sugar Coates
Larry Marshall
as Cab Calloway
Joe Dallesandro
as Charles `Lucky' Luciano
Ed O'Ross
as Monk
Frederic Downs Jr.
as Sullen Man
Diane Venora
as Gloria Swanson
Glenn Withrow
as Ed Popke
Tucker Smallwood
as Kid Griffin
Woody Strode
as Holmes
Kim Chan
as Ling
Ed Rowan
as Messiah
Rony Clanton
as Caspar Holstein
Damien Leake
as Bub Jewett
Bill Cobbs
as Bib Joe Ison
Joe Lynn
as Marcial Flores
Sandra Beall
as Myrtle Fay
Zane Mark
as Duke Ellington
Tom Signorelli
as Butch Murdock
Steve Vignari
as Trigger Mike Coppola
Gregory Rozakis
as Charlie Chaplin
Bruce Howard
as Bumpy Hood
Marc Coppola
as Ted Husing
Norma Jean Darden
as Elida Webb
Robert Earl Jones
as Stage-Door Joe
Vincent Jerosa
as James Cagney
Rosalind Harris
as Fanny Brice
Bruce MacVittie
as Vince Hood
Brian Tarantina
as Vince Hood
George Cantero
as Vince Hood
James Russo
as Vince Hood
Giancarlo Esposito
as Bumpy Hood
Bruce Hubbard
as Bumpy Hood
Ed Zang
as Clerk
Christopher Lewis
as Child in Street
Ralph Brown
as Hoofer
Sarita Allen
as Dancer
Tracey Bass
as Dancer
Carla Earle
as Dancer
Wendy Edmead
as Dancer
Sonia Hensley
as Dancer
Nicholas J. Giangiulio
as Screen Test Thug
John P. Ryan
as Joe Flynn
Bruce Howard
as Bumpy Hood
Show More Cast

Critic Reviews for The Cotton Club

All Critics (24) | Top Critics (5)

Given its garish production history, one rather expected The Cotton Club to sing with hot-jazz desperation. Instead, we get the mediocre craftsmanship of a pit band in Vegas.

Full Review… | March 13, 2009
TIME Magazine
Top Critic

It was the most assured film Coppola had made in a decade, full of casual wit and visual invention.

Full Review… | December 11, 2007
Chicago Reader
Top Critic

The narrative is a mess despite the simplistic twinning of tales.

Full Review… | June 23, 2006
Time Out
Top Critic

No excerpt available.

July 7, 2005
St. Louis Post-Dispatch
Top Critic

Whatever it took to do it, Coppola has extracted a very special film out of the checkered history of this project.

Full Review… | October 23, 2004
Chicago Sun-Times
Top Critic

Sharply uneven, Coppola's period musical about he famous Harlem club is lavishly produced but shallow.

Full Review… | August 24, 2012
EmanuelLevy.Com

Audience Reviews for The Cotton Club

The main reason why I watched this was that I worked on a stage show starring Maurice Hines and he mentioned this as a highlight of his and his brother's career. Most of the song and dance numbers don't advance the plot, which weakens the story overall. However, it is too bad that this lost so much money upon release because, separately, the musical numbers and the plot about crime and fame have such good production values. Gregory and Maurice Hines play tap dancing brothers based on their own relationship and performing styles. Gregory's character goes solo at the famous Cotton Club in Harlem, which was only open to white audiences. His character falls for a woman of mixed race. Otherwise, Coppola and whoever really deserves credit for writing don't seem to know how to develop the black characters. They are still pushed to the background. Bob Hoskins and James Remar play real life gangsters, Owney Madden and Dutch Schultz, respectively. Richard Gere and Nicolas Cage play a pair of brothers, as well. And each of them is loosely based on a real person, though not a real pair of brothers. Gere, who is really playing the trumpet on the soundtrack, plays the character Dixie Dwyer, who is likely a version of the 30s and 40s actor George Raft. The award nominated editing and art direction are eye catching. Coppola does generally direct a team that can visually quote other classic films of the genre and the era. But mainly, because of the ensemble cast, and actors playing celebrities in cameo roles, this deserves another look.

Byron Brubaker
Byron Brubaker

Super Reviewer

½

Good motion picture, but The Cotton Club presents some cliches of gangsters movies. Whatever, Coppola made a remarkable film.

Lucas Martins
Lucas Martins

Super Reviewer

While not the Godfather (and what is really...besides Godfather 2, but I digress) The Cotton Club is a great entertaining little movie. All controversy about it's making aside Coppola and Evans managed to craft a thoroughly entertaining film with several great scenes and mostly solid performances (I'm looking at you Nic Cage and James Remar). I can say however, that this is hands down, the single best tap dancing gangster film ever made.

Ken Stachnik
Ken Stachnik

Super Reviewer

Discussion Forum

Discuss The Cotton Club on our Movie forum!

News & Features