Penn Badgley Joel Larsen Actor Josh Wise Pat Brody Actor Angela Goethals Cheryl Larsen Actor Gigi Rice Karen Larsen Actor Michael Milhoan Bill Larsen Actor Natasha Melnick Isabelle Meyers Actor Melinda Sward Guest Star Ben Stein Guest Star Tom Wilson Guest Star Rick Wiener Executive Producer, Writer Kenny Schwartz Executive Producer, Writer Warren Littlefield Executive Producer Lev Spiro Director Michael Lange Director Marsha Myers Writer Shawn Levy Director Michael Alan Spiller Director Bryan Gordon Director Neal Israel Director Casey Johnson Writer Alan R. Cohen Writer Josh Bycel Writer Rick Weiner Writer David Windsor Writer Alan Freedland Writer Jon Fener Writer