Into The Dark: Season 2 Episode 2 Reviews
![]() | Jack Wilhelmi ScreenRant | December 3, 2019 Into The Dark finally delivered an incredible Thanksgiving horror story that sticks to the tradition of the First Thanksgiving and boasts a relentless, brutal ending. | ||
| Kate Sánchez But Why Tho? A Geek Community | November 6, 2019 Overall Pilgrim is fun, it's gory, and it will fill you with gratitude for the partnership between Blumhouse and Hulu. Perfect for the Thanksgiving theme. Full Review | Original Score: 8/10 | ||
![]() | John Serba Decider | November 6, 2019 Pilgrim is among the best Into the Dark entries because it's willing to stir some s***, break some eggs and let the chips fall where they may. | ||
| Matt Donato Slashfilm | November 6, 2019 Pilgrim is an evil Thanksgiving tale with all the death-soaked trimmings. Full Review | Original Score: 7.5/10 | ||
| Sarah Musnicky Nightmarish Conjurings | November 4, 2019 While the acting itself was good, I definitely couldn't help really enjoying and being sucked into the progressively disturbing atmosphere that Dunstan was creating for us onscreen. | ||
| Kristy Puchko Pajiba | November 4, 2019 Murky in its vision, lazy in its character development, uninspired in its violent spectacle, and stodgy in its pacing. | ||
![]() | Richard Whittaker Austin Chronicle | November 4, 2019 Where Pilgrim does work is as a nasty, sloppy slice of occasionally gory fun, chock-full of purposefully silly chills and ridiculous shocks. | ||
![]() | Eddie Strait The Daily Dot | November 1, 2019 Pilgrim takes the worst aspects of the holiday season-forced gratitude and bonding-and weaponizes them. Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/5 | ||
![]() | Brian Tallerico RogerEbert.com | Top Critic | November 1, 2019 This is one of the best chapters of Into the Dark because it actually has something to say about the holiday it uses. Full Review | Original Score: 3/4 | |
![]() | Peter Martin ScreenAnarchy | November 1, 2019 The evil people in this piece are equal-opportunity villains: they treat everyone horribly, regardless of skin color. Full Review | Original Score: 2.5/5 |