Richard Gabai Director, Producer Amanda Michalka Hannah Yoder Actor Jesse McCartney Josh Actor Jean-Luc Bilodeau Samual Actor Alyson Stoner Mary Actor Cayden Boyd Isaac Actor Aurelia Scheppers Sarah Actor Ron Ely Elder Miller Actor Brian Krause Mr. Yoder Actor Avery Kristen Pohl Beth Actor Micah Tayloe Owens Gabe Actor Carrie Wampler Jennifer Actor Pauline Dyer Lisa Actor Michael Amato Producer John Constantine Producer Jeff Murphy Producer, Film Editing Scott Peck Producer, Cinematographer Michael Constantine Executive Producer Richard Iott Executive Producer David Gabai Executive Producer Sean Murray Original Music Don Carroll Casting Niko Vilaivongs Production Design Rebekah Bell Set Decoration Deborah Goldstein Costume Design