Three Identical Strangers

Critics Consensus

Surreal and surprising, Three Identical Strangers effectively questions the nature of reality and identity.

96%

TOMATOMETER

Reviews Counted: 171

88%
liked it

Audience Score

User Ratings: 2,717

TOMATOMETER

N/A
All Critics | Top Critics
Average Rating: N/A
Reviews Count: 0
Fresh: 0
Rotten: 0

AUDIENCE SCORE

88%
Average Rating: 4.1/5

You may have noticed some of the recent changes we have made. To read more about what we’ve been working on behind the scenes, please check out our new RT Product Blog here.


Want to See

Add Rating
My Rating    

Three Identical Strangers Videos

Three Identical Strangers Photos

Movie Info

Three strangers are reunited by astonishing coincidence after being born identical triplets, separated at birth, and adopted by three different families. Their jaw-dropping, feel-good story instantly becomes a global sensation complete with fame and celebrity, however, the fairy-tale reunion sets in motion a series of events that unearth an unimaginable secret -- a secret with radical repercussions for us all.

Watch it now

Cast

News & Interviews for Three Identical Strangers

Critic Reviews for Three Identical Strangers

All Critics (171) | Top Critics (36)

  • It combines interviews, archive footage and dramatic reconstructions to take us as close in to the story as possible, not coming to any conclusions. You won't be able to look away.

    Feb 28, 2019 | Rating: 4/5 | Full Review…
  • It never loses sight of the three scarred subjects at the core of the tale, and of the sense of profound injustice inflicted on blameless children. Unmissable.

    Dec 3, 2018 | Rating: 5/5 | Full Review…

    Kevin Maher

    Times (UK)
    Top Critic
  • It is as gripping as a first-contact sci-fi.

    Nov 28, 2018 | Rating: 4/5 | Full Review…
  • Like Morris's work, the film has an abstract side as well as a concrete one, carrying a unique story to a point where broader philosophical issues open up.

    Sep 14, 2018 | Rating: 3/5 | Full Review…
  • An engrossing, heartbreaking journey.

    Jul 13, 2018 | Rating: 3/4 | Full Review…
  • Zooms in on the nature versus nurture question that has entranced, irritated and boggled humans for centuries.

    Jul 13, 2018 | Rating: B+ | Full Review…

    Tom Long

    Detroit News
    Top Critic

Audience Reviews for Three Identical Strangers

I honestly don't know why anyone would find this story so amazing and incredible - a story that is actually filled with vague speculation and moralizing about the separation of twin babies - but what I find really unbelievable is how these boys became famous just because of that.

Carlos Magalhães
Carlos Magalhães

Super Reviewer

½

The last three or so minutes of this thing will get you despite it dragging slightly from moment to moment in the last half hour. Utterly, utterly fascinating stuff here that is as much about nature versus nurture as it is context, context, context. To this point, the editing is outstanding. Hesitant to say much more about it as I knew little to nothing walking in and came out completely chilled and rather mystified. Will certainly come back to this again (and probably again & again). Cannot stop thinking about it.

Philip Price
Philip Price

Super Reviewer

½

It gets a little too saccharine in some of its conclusions, especially when you consider all the dark turns the narrative takes, but perhaps that is an effort to rebuke the cruelty inflicted on these people. Regardless its a compelling narrative.

Alec Barniskis
Alec Barniskis

Super Reviewer

½

GEEZ LOUISE! - My Review of THREE IDENTICAL STRANGERS (3 1/2 Stars) Tim Wardle's documentary, THREE IDENTICAL STRANGERS, isn't the sort of film that sneaks up on you, since it rushes out of the gate with such an entertaining burst of energy. Employing somewhat distracting, soft focus reenactment footage with direct-to-camera talking heads, he tells the story of identical triplets, separated at birth in 1961 and who meet for the first time when they're 19 years old. A random case of mistaken identity on Bobby's first day of college leads him to discover he has a twin brother, Eddy. When their meeting makes the news, David sees himself in the pair, leading to their joyous reunion. Dressing and acting alike, all with infectious, toothy grins and dynamic energy, they find instant fame on the talk show circuit and even make a brief cameo appearance in Madonna's breakout film, DESPERATELY SEEKING SUSAN. This section is enough for a fun, human interest story, but clearly not enough for a movie. Something darker must await the audience. Once the dust settles, questions start to arise. None of their adoptive parents knew their children were born triplets, a fact kept from them by the Louise Wise adoption agency, which primarily helped find homes for Jewish adoptees. When the parents confront the Wise's Board of Directors, something seems a little off. It reminded me of the next door neighbor gatherings in ROSEMARY'S BABY, with Louise Wise and her gang guilty of something despite their warm smiles. It turns chilling, especially in interviews with a peripheral person to the agency who either will make complete sense to you, or you'll be shocked by the banality of her brand of evil. I won't spoil where all this leads, but suffice it to say, this humorous look at how nature can produce seemingly identical people despite the fact that they were raised in completely different ways, turns very sad and very dark. The role of nurture comes into play, especially as the onion layers get peeled off to reveal three distinct personalities. By the end, you're left wondering what shaped each of their lives, what informed their behavior, and how much of it was instinctual versus learned. It's fun tracing the rise of the brothers, who clearly had a thirst for fame. It's a rags, rags, rags to riches, riches, riches and back again story. You feel their flush of love for each other but can see the sadness in their eyes as they tell their stories. It's a deeply unsettling experience to watch. I'm not convinced that Wardle gets as far as he can with his subjects. They seem to hold back a little, perhaps minimizing the terrible downside which befell them after meeting. You wonder if they would have been better off blissfully unaware of their past. All told, THREE IDENTICAL STRANGERS is a terrifying piece of work. It may force you to not trust elation. It opens your eyes to the fact that even the people who appear to do good in the world may not have your best interests in mind. As a world currently filled with a surplus of trust issues, the film plays right into that. It's a killjoy, a good killjoy, but a killjoy just the same.

Glenn Gaylord
Glenn Gaylord

Super Reviewer

Three Identical Strangers Quotes

There are no approved quotes yet for this movie.

News & Features