David Wain Director, Writer, Co-Producer Janeane Garofalo Beth Actor David Hyde Pierce Henry Newman Actor Michael Showalter Coop Actor, Writer, Co-Producer Marguerite Moreau Katie Actor Paul Rudd Andy Actor Zak Orth J.J. Actor Christopher Meloni Gene Actor A.D. Miles Gary Actor Molly Shannon Gail Actor Gideon Jacobs Aaron Actor Ken Marino Victor Actor Joe Lo Truglio Neil Actor Michael Ian Black McKinley Actor Liam Norton Arty Actor Amy Poehler Susie Actor Bradley Cooper Ben Actor Marisa Ryan Abby Actor Elizabeth Banks Lindsay Actor Gabriel Millman Caped Boy Actor Kevin Sussman Steve Actor Howard Bernstein Producer Benjamin Weinstein Cinematographer Mark White Production Design Meg Reticker Film Editing Jill Kliber Costume Design Jill Rubin Line Producer, Unit Production Manager Theodore Shapiro Music Craig Wedren Music Susie Farris Casting Howard Gertler Associate Producer Chip Signore First Assistant Director Samantha Lavin Second Assistant Director