Alfred Hitchcock Host, Executive Producer Robert Reiner 1st Cop Actor Eduardo Ciannelli The Priest Actor Edmund Hashim El Magnifico Actor Walter Kinsella Lt. Morgan Guest Star Michael Dunne Rick Sheffield Actor George Kane 2nd Cop Actor Gail Bonney Actor Kreg Martin Benny Actor Charles Carlson Lawrence Westbrook Actor Bert Remsen Jimmy - Bartender Actor Hinton Pope 1st Cop Actor Molly Glessing Parlor Maid Actor Karl Lukas Uncle Ben - Bar Owner Actor Howard McLeod 2nd Cop Actor Andy Romano The Young Workman Actor Eve McVeagh Mrs. Archer Actor Olan Soule Darlene's Daddy Actor Tom Gilleran The Delivery Man Actor John Zaremba Market Manager Actor Henry Slesar Writer Bryce Walton Writer Calvin Clements Sr. Writer James P. Cavanagh Writer John Collier Writer Harold Swanton Writer William Link Writer Talmage Powell Writer Robert Wallsten Writer Alan Crosland Jr. Director Paul Henreid Director Norman Lloyd Director Robert Florey Director Robert Bloch Writer Richard Levinson Writer Stanley Ellin Writer John Newland Director Bernard Girard Director Boris Sagal Director