Adriana Lima Host, Executive Producer Sir John Actor Sarah Brown Judge Russell James Judge Amanda Terry Contestant Andrew Velazquez Contestant Catherine Shim Contestant Corey Ford Contestant Danny Jelaca Contestant Jenny Strebe Contestant John Blaine Contestant Kym Nicole Oubre Contestant Mitchell Halliday Contestant Sandy Poirier Contestant Silvia Reis Contestant Tyme the Infamous Contestant Chris Appleton Guest Ta'Rhonda Jones Guest Elaine Welteroth Guest Gail Federici Guest Norton Herrick Executive Producer Ross Elliot Executive Producer Christian Murphy Executive Producer