Forest Whitaker Special Agent Sam Cooper Actor Janeane Garofalo Beth Griffith Actor Michael Kelly John "Prophet" Sims Actor Beau Garrett Gina LaSalle Actor Matt Ryan Mick Rawson Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor Lukas Behnken Lucas Behnken Guest Star Nathan Anderson Kevin Laughlin Guest Star Amanda Foreman Susan Laughlin Guest Star Shyloh Oostwald Cindy Laughlin Guest Star Annie Burgstede Tami Vinoda Guest Star Mirron E. Willis Sgt. Potter Guest Star Joe Peracchio Otis Meredith Guest Star Elmarie Wendel Paula Guest Star Kevin West Gary Guest Star David Aaron Baker Grant Nichols Guest Star Jennifer Riker Kristen Nichols Guest Star Ava Allan Erica Nichols Guest Star Adeye Sahran Grant's Assistant Guest Star Chris Mundy Executive Producer Edward Allen Bernero Executive Producer Mark Gordon Executive Producer Deborah Spera Executive Producer Stephen Cragg Writer Shintaro Shimosawa Director