Pete Holmes Tom Actor Katie Lowes Jen Actor Chi McBride Archie Actor Julie White Helen Actor Mason Wells Sam Actor Tahj Mowry Lewell Guest Star Amanda Perez Tia Guest Star Matthew J. McCarthy Carl Guest Star Judy Kain Mimi Guest Star Sheryl Lee Ralph Loretta Guest Star Mark Gross Executive Producer David Hollander Executive Producer Brian d'Arcy James Executive Producer Janene Lin Writer Mark Cendrowski Director