Michael Dorman Joe Pickett Actor David Alan Grier Vern Dunnegan Actor Julianna Guill Marybeth Pickett Actor Sharon Lawrence Missy Actor Paul Sparks Wacey Actor Mustafa Speaks Nate Romanowski Actor Skywalker Hughes Sheridan Pickett Actor Kamyrn Pilva Lucy Pickett Actor Patrick Gallagher Sheriff Barnum Actor Chad Rook Deputy McLanahan Actor Benjamin Hollingsworth Ote Keeley Actor Leah Gibson Jeannie Keeley Actor Aadila Dosani Cricket Actor C.J. Box Executive Producer Doug Wick Executive Producer Drew Dowdle Executive Producer John Erick Dowdle Executive Producer Lucy Fisher Executive Producer