Gene Stupnitsky Creator, Executive Producer Lee Eisenberg Creator, Executive Producer James Marsden James Marsden Actor Ronald Gladden Self Alan Barinholtz Judge Alan Rosen Actor Susan Berger Barbara Goldstein Actor Cassandra Blair Vanessa Jenkins Actor Kirk Fox Pat McCurdy Actor Ross Kimball Ross Kubiak Actor Pramode Kumar Ravi Chattapodhyay Actor Trisha LaFache Debra LaSeur Actor Mekki Leeper Noah Price Actor Edy Modica Jeannie Abruzzo Actor Kerry O'Neill Officer Christine Sugalski Actor Rashida "Sheedz" Olayiwola Officer Nikki Wilder Actor Whitney Rice Jacquiline Hilgrove Actor Maria Russell Inez De Leon Actor Ishmel Sahid Lonnie Coleman Actor Ben Seaward Trevor Morris Actor Ron Song Ken Hyun Actor David Brown Todd Gregory Actor Rashida Olayiwola Officer Nikki Wilder Actor Evan Williams Shaun Sanders Actor Lauren Burns Samantha Actor Marcos González Bailiff Actor Timothy E. Goodwin Jake the Plumber Actor Garrett Hoo Martin Li Actor Damian Joseph Quinn Customer Actor Bunny Levine Prospective Juror Actor Luke Millington-Drake Customer Actor Ben Official Server Actor Biff Wiff Steve Actor David Bernad Executive Producer Ruben Fleischer Executive Producer Nicholas Hatton Executive Producer Cody Heller Executive Producer Todd Schulman Executive Producer Jake Szymanski Executive Producer, Director Andrew Weinberg Executive Producer