Jeremy Sisto George Altman Actor Jane Levy Tessa Altman Actor Cheryl Hines Dallas Royce Actor Allie Grant Lisa Shay Actor Chris Parnell Fred Shay Actor Ana Gasteyer Sheila Shay Actor Carly Chaikin Dalia Royce Actor Alan Tudyk Guest Star Zabeth Russell Guest Star Mae Whitman Guest Star J.R. Nutt Guest Star Ryan Kolbe Guest Star August Maturo Guest Star Siri Miller Guest Star Julie Wittner Guest Star Monica Young Guest Star Edward Padilla Guest Star Shane Kaufman Guest Star Cody Chappel Guest Star Chantelle Tibbs Guest Star Lydia Woods Guest Star Emily Kapnek Executive Producer Patricia Breen Executive Producer Brian Chamberlayne Writer Stuart McDonald Director