Alison Sweeney Host Jaquin Allen Contestant Lariamly Allen Contestant Ana Alvarado Contestant Irene Alvarado Contestant Austin Andrews Contestant Ken Andrews Contestant Courtney Crozier Contestant Hannah Curlee Contestant Dan Evans Contestant Rulon Gardner Contestant Jay Jacobs Contestant Denise Hill Contestant Jennifer Jacobs Contestant Marci Crozier Contestant Don Evans Contestant Moses Kinikini Contestant Kaylee Kinikini Contestant Sarah Nitta Contestant Olivia Ward Contestant Arthur Wornum Contestant Justin Pope Contestant Jesse Wornum Contestant Curtis Stone Guest Star Lorena Garcia Guest Star Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer