Dick Van Dyke Rob Petrie Actor Mary Tyler Moore Laura Petrie Actor Rose Marie Sally Rogers Actor Morey Amsterdam Maurice "Buddy" Sorrell Actor Sandy Kenyon Doctor Guest Star Larry Mathews Ritchie Petrie Actor Ray Kellogg Corporal Guest Star Richard Deacon Mel Cooley Actor Jerry Paris Jerry Helper Actor, Director Charles Cantor Bartender Guest Star Ann Morgan Guilbert Millie Helper Actor Phil Arnold Waiter Guest Star Danny Thomas Kolac Guest Star Herbie Faye Deli Man Guest Star Geraldine Wall Miss Glasser (cat owner) Guest Star Carl Reiner Game Show Host Guest Voice, Writer Joan Shawlee Pickles Sorrell Guest Star Jerry Hausner Mr. Fletcher Guest Star Frank Adamo Veterinarian's Assistant Guest Star Roxanne Berard Miss Thomas Evelyn Guest Star John Rich Director Coby Ruskin Director Hal Cooper Director Claudio Guzmán Director James Niver Director Alan Rafkin Director Sheldon Leonard Director Sheldon Keller Writer Martin Ragaway Writer Ray Allen Saffian Writer John Whedon Writer Bill Idelson Writer Lee Erwin Writer Howard Merrill Writer Ronald Alexander Writer Harvey Bullock Writer Ray Brenner Writer Jack Guss Writer