Queen Latifah Detective Grasso Actor Chosen Jacobs Charlie Chambers Actor Sophie Thatcher Becky Monroe Actor Sam Strike Casper Tatum Actor Ben Ahlers Brad Kirchoff Actor Julia Sarah Stone Berlice Actor Mark Duplass Mr. Carpenter Actor Tony Hale Mr. Boque Actor Kristine Froseth Chrissy Monroe Actor Nnamdi Asomugha Adult Charlie Chambers Actor David James Lewis Mr. Jablonski Guest Star Eddie O'Keefe Executive Producer, Writer Chris Hutton Executive Producer, Writer Rebecca Thomas Executive Producer, Director Tariq Merhab Executive Producer Chad Hamilton Executive Producer