Matt Bomer Neal Caffrey Actor Tim DeKay Peter Burke Actor Tiffani Thiessen Elizabeth Burke Actor Willie Garson Mozzie Actor Natalie Morales Lauren Cruz Actor Susan Misner Dana Mitchell Guest Star Garret Dillahunt Patrick Aimes Guest Star Sarah Wynter Alisha Teagan Guest Star Chris Stack John Mitchell Guest Star Brad Lee Wind Phil the Guard Guest Star Kate Shindle Female Anchor Guest Star Jonathan C. Stewart Leonard the Sports Guy Guest Star Eric L. Abrams Dispatcher (as Eric Lenox Abrams) Guest Star Kevin Carolan Senior Producer Guest Star Margaret Anne Florence Business Woman Guest Star Geno Segers Aimes' Bodyguard Guest Star Jeff Eastin Executive Producer