Glenn Casale Director, Screenwriter Gary Halvorson Director Cathy Rigby Peter Pan Actor Barbara McCulloh Mrs. Darling , Mermaid Actor Sam Zeller Starkey Actor Elisa Sagardia Wendy Moira Angela Darling Actor Barry Cavanagh John Darling Actor Drake English Michael Darling Actor Dana Solimando Liza , Tiger Lily Actor Thomas Buck Mason Nana , Bill Jukes , Crocodile Actor Paul Schoeffler Mr. Darling , Captain Hook Actor Alon Williams Curly Actor Hally McGehean Tootles Actor Michael Nostrand Mr. Smee Actor Jerome Robbins Screenwriter Marc Bauman Producer Tom McCoy Executive Producer Kris Slava Executive Producer David Walmsley Executive Producer Brent Carpenter Film Editing Kris Trexler Film Editing Julia Flores Casting John Iacovelli Production Design, Art Director