Neill Fearnley Minister Director, Actor Jill Wagner Annie Hancock Actor Colin Egglesfield Ben Lawson Actor Rachel Hayward Jessica Hancock Actor Ken Tremblett Hal Hancock Actor Bill Dow Hector Actor Matty Finochio Tony McAllister Actor Tasya Teles Giovanna Jorgensen Actor Michael Karl Richards Joe Actor Ivy Matheson Young Annie Actor Matt Visser Young Ben Actor Eric Gustafsson Young Joe Actor Marilyn Norry Tracy Actor Daniel Bacon Preacher Actor Catherine Lough Haggquist Judge Brown Actor Fiona Vroom Mary Lou Actor Laurie Stevens Screenwriter Holly Redford Producer Bruce D. Johnson Executive Producer David Pelletier Cinematographer Jason Pielak Film Editing Stu Goldberg Original Music Sean Cossey Casting J.J. Ogilvy Casting Rick Whitfield Production Design