Roger Spottiswoode Director Stockard Channing Judy Shepard Actor Sam Waterston Dennis Shepard Actor Shane Meier Matthew Shepard Actor Kristen Thompson Romaine Patterson Actor Joseph Ziegler Cal Actor B.J. McLellan Logan Shepard Actor David Broadhurst Logan Shepard Actor Yani Gellman Pablo Actor Damien Atkins Donny Actor, Actor Drew Nelson Lance Actor Philip Eddolls Aaron McKinney Actor Paul Robbins Russell Henderson Actor Nazneen Contractor Shima Actor Wendy Crewson Sarah Actor Eduardo Gomez Gomez Actor Ray Kahnert Minister Actor Jim Alderidge Jury Foreman Actor Makyla Smith Casey Actor Bruce Beaton Cowboy Actor Brian Frank Neighbour Actor Sadie LeBlanc Girlfriend Actor Jim Codrington Health Food Store Manager Actor James Bearden Protester Actor Patricia Carroll Brown Angry Mourner Actor Lindsay Murrell Matthew's Date Actor Susan Chuang Female News Anchor Actor John Henry Canavan Painter Actor Dorothy Gordon Elderly Woman Actor Dinah Watts Cal's Secretary Actor Scott Wickware Bartender Actor Clara George Producer Goldie Hawn Executive Producer Peter Sussman Executive Producer Ed Gernon Executive Producer John Wierick Writer Jacob Krueger Writer