Grizzly Man Reviews

  • Apr 08, 2021

    Timothy Treadwell auditioning for a role in the sitcom Cheers was an interesting little factoid. Anyway, the guy was definitely passionate, and also borderline insane/delusional, which is what makes this story fascinating in many parts. There's literally a moment where he films himself caressing bear doodoo. If that isn't devotion, I don't know what is.

    Timothy Treadwell auditioning for a role in the sitcom Cheers was an interesting little factoid. Anyway, the guy was definitely passionate, and also borderline insane/delusional, which is what makes this story fascinating in many parts. There's literally a moment where he films himself caressing bear doodoo. If that isn't devotion, I don't know what is.

  • Mar 06, 2021

    Approached from many different angles, the story of Grizzly Man is kind of incredible. Now that I have seen it a couple of different times, I am finding that I am drawing very different conclusions about Timothy Treadwell now than I did 5-10 years ago. In some ways, he absolutely seems like a victim and in other ways, he seems to have really done a great of manipulating other people and taking them down with him. Grizzly Man is a must-watch because of Treadwell's complexity and the nuance of the issues which surround him and this story.

    Approached from many different angles, the story of Grizzly Man is kind of incredible. Now that I have seen it a couple of different times, I am finding that I am drawing very different conclusions about Timothy Treadwell now than I did 5-10 years ago. In some ways, he absolutely seems like a victim and in other ways, he seems to have really done a great of manipulating other people and taking them down with him. Grizzly Man is a must-watch because of Treadwell's complexity and the nuance of the issues which surround him and this story.

  • Feb 03, 2021

    Grizzly Man is a sad and maddening documentary. It kept me up all night after viewing it. I share Werner Herzog's interpretation Tim Treadwell was a brilliant but delusional activist (not his words, but the sentiment I picked up). Treadwell wasn't naive--he knew very well he could die out in the wilderness, and seemed to expect it one day. It takes a certain type of intelligence to survive in the bush for 13 straight summers, up close and personal with giant predators. Where his delusion came in is thinking nature is ultimately harmonious and should be benign. I thought Herzog went too far in saying nature is murderous, but agree with his notion nature is chaotic. I would agree more with the Aleut man who criticized Treadwell for intruding on nature. The Aleut people kept a respectful distance from the bears. Nature needs to be recognized as chaotic (not necessarily murderous, as that implies malice intent), and should be respected. Treadwell viewed himself as the lone protector of bears, even though bears can protect themselves and weren't in any particular danger from poachers in the remote national park. We see Treadwell approaching bears who don't seem to appreciate his advances, and at one point rerouting a stream to funnel more salmon into the bears' habitat. My personal theory, based on my unprofessional opinion of Treadwell's apparent bipolar disorder, is that after his confrontation with the Air Alaska employee which sent him angrily back into the wild, he got himself worked up to a point there was no where to go but down. He went back out there in an elaborate suicide attempt. What is unforgivable is he took his girlfriend down with him. Ultimately, it is my opinion the bears became his gods. Multiple times in the movie the interviewees mention he had religious experiences living among the bears. Carl Jung said your religion will eat you alive, and that is what literally happened here. In his delusion he thought he was the bears' savior, and in a perverse sense, it was his intention to become a Eucharistic sacrifice for them. Fascinating, but also deeply troubling.

    Grizzly Man is a sad and maddening documentary. It kept me up all night after viewing it. I share Werner Herzog's interpretation Tim Treadwell was a brilliant but delusional activist (not his words, but the sentiment I picked up). Treadwell wasn't naive--he knew very well he could die out in the wilderness, and seemed to expect it one day. It takes a certain type of intelligence to survive in the bush for 13 straight summers, up close and personal with giant predators. Where his delusion came in is thinking nature is ultimately harmonious and should be benign. I thought Herzog went too far in saying nature is murderous, but agree with his notion nature is chaotic. I would agree more with the Aleut man who criticized Treadwell for intruding on nature. The Aleut people kept a respectful distance from the bears. Nature needs to be recognized as chaotic (not necessarily murderous, as that implies malice intent), and should be respected. Treadwell viewed himself as the lone protector of bears, even though bears can protect themselves and weren't in any particular danger from poachers in the remote national park. We see Treadwell approaching bears who don't seem to appreciate his advances, and at one point rerouting a stream to funnel more salmon into the bears' habitat. My personal theory, based on my unprofessional opinion of Treadwell's apparent bipolar disorder, is that after his confrontation with the Air Alaska employee which sent him angrily back into the wild, he got himself worked up to a point there was no where to go but down. He went back out there in an elaborate suicide attempt. What is unforgivable is he took his girlfriend down with him. Ultimately, it is my opinion the bears became his gods. Multiple times in the movie the interviewees mention he had religious experiences living among the bears. Carl Jung said your religion will eat you alive, and that is what literally happened here. In his delusion he thought he was the bears' savior, and in a perverse sense, it was his intention to become a Eucharistic sacrifice for them. Fascinating, but also deeply troubling.

  • Dec 23, 2020

    He was incredible person. But this film is not as good as Timothy was.

    He was incredible person. But this film is not as good as Timothy was.

  • Dec 15, 2020

    Utterly fascinating.

    Utterly fascinating.

  • Sep 10, 2020

    Ok, with good scenery but a dude who gets killed by the bears he reveres, really ?

    Ok, with good scenery but a dude who gets killed by the bears he reveres, really ?

  • Aug 16, 2020

    Brilliantly tells the extraordinary story of an extraordinary man. Haunting stuff.

    Brilliantly tells the extraordinary story of an extraordinary man. Haunting stuff.

  • Aug 08, 2020

    I think the subject matter is the main problem. It would work much better as a short documentary than a full-length feature. The intrigue of Timothy Treadwell's expeditions wear off very quickly and the movie resorts to playing long clips of his video documentaries which becomes tiring. I thought people's different perspectives on Timothy's character was interesting and obviously the day he died, but other than that I do not believe Herzog had a character that was compelling enough for a full length documentary.

    I think the subject matter is the main problem. It would work much better as a short documentary than a full-length feature. The intrigue of Timothy Treadwell's expeditions wear off very quickly and the movie resorts to playing long clips of his video documentaries which becomes tiring. I thought people's different perspectives on Timothy's character was interesting and obviously the day he died, but other than that I do not believe Herzog had a character that was compelling enough for a full length documentary.

  • Jul 05, 2020

    Gotta love documentaries.. Grizzly Man proves how far certain people test themselves with their live; zany and spectacular.

    Gotta love documentaries.. Grizzly Man proves how far certain people test themselves with their live; zany and spectacular.

  • Jun 03, 2020

    Fascinating but sad story about an unwell individual. Werner Herzog did a good job combining Treadwell's footage with interviews of those involved with his life and death.

    Fascinating but sad story about an unwell individual. Werner Herzog did a good job combining Treadwell's footage with interviews of those involved with his life and death.