Becca Gleason Director, Screenwriter Joey King Jamie Actor Andrea Savage Shira Actor June Squibb Dotty Actor Erin Darke Hope Actor Paul Scheer Ned Actor Jack Kilmer Luke Actor Kelly Lamor Wilson Emily Actor Stephen Ruffin March Actor Travis James Buck Actor Logan Medina Dylan Actor Bill Eudaly Father Patrick Actor Paul Ryden Randall Smithton Actor Eyal Rimmon Producer Alexandre Dauman Producer Jim Kaufman Executive Producer Gideon Tadmor Executive Producer Ben Hardwicke Cinematographer Josie Azzam Film Editing Nathan Matthew David Original Music Sam Hensen Production Design Naomi Smith Art Director Stefanie Del Papa Costume Design Jordan Blair Mangold Brown Casting