Mark Webber Mark Director, Actor, Screenwriter, Executive Producer Isaac Love Isaac Actor Shannyn Sossamon Lydia Actor Jocelin Donahue Jocelin Actor Michael Cera Michael Actor Jason Ritter Jason Actor Amanda Seyfried Self Tim Dowlin Tim Actor Aubrey Plaza Aubrey Actor Mimi Moss Midwife Actor Diana Peña Maria Actor Liz Destro Producer Mollie Engelhart Producer Daniel McGilvray Producer Matt Sprague Producer Tim Ryan Executive Producer Patrice Lucien Cochet Cinematographer Sven Pape Film Editing Michael Hersey Production Design Alexi Gomez Art Director Negar Ali Costume Design Dominika Posserén Casting Kelly Wagner Casting