Michael Lembeck Director Tim Allen Scott Calvin, Santa Claus, Toy Santa Claus Actor Elizabeth Mitchell Carol Newman Actor David Krumholtz Head Elf Bernard Actor Eric Lloyd Charlie Actor Judge Reinhold Neil Actor Wendy Crewson Laura Miller Actor Spencer Breslin Number Two Elf Curtis Actor Liliana Mumy Lucy Actor Danielle Woodman Abby Actor Aisha Tyler Mother Nature Actor Kevin Pollak Cupid Actor Jay Thomas Easter Bunny Actor Michael Dorn Sandman Actor Don Rhymer Screenwriter Cinco Paul Screenwriter Ken Daurio Screenwriter Ed Decter Screenwriter John Strauss Screenwriter Steve Rudnick Writer, Writer Leo Benvenuti Writer, Writer Brian Reilly Producer Bobby Newmyer Producer Jeffrey Silver Producer William W. Wilson III Executive Producer Rick Messina Executive Producer Richard Baker Executive Producer James Miller Executive Producer Adam Greenberg Cinematographer Tony Burrough Production Design David Finfer Film Editing George S. Clinton Music Frankie Pine Music Supervisor Tom Woodruff Jr. Special Makeup Effects Alec Gillis Special Makeup Effects