Gary Yates Director, Screenwriter Torrey DeVitto Madison Rush Actor Zane Holtz Connor Avery Actor Amanda Barker Edna Prescott Actor Tanisha Thammavongsa Hayley Actor Sophie Bastelle Lena DeLorean Actor Shawn Ahmed Jefferson Actor Richard Waugh Livingston Actor Jennie Esnard Judge Actor Ava Weiss Beth Prescott Actor Jonathan Neil Alexander Sean Actor Morgan Saunders Josie Avery Actor Yvette McKoy Sophia Farentino Actor Duane Keogh Walter Actor Evert Houston Historian Actor Kiera Meeks Stage Crew Actor Eddie Bizarria Town Crier , Bailiff Actor Dave Rose Bookstore Reader Actor C. Jay Cox Screenwriter Shane Boucher Producer, Production Design Caitlin Delaney Producer Jesse Prupas Executive Producer Jonas Prupas Executive Producer William Smith Cinematographer Ryan Kovack Film Editing Kristjan Bergey Original Music Jodie Rice Art Director Jennifer Stroud Costume Design Larissa Mair Casting Ilona Smyth Casting