Oliver Thompson Director, Screenwriter, Producer, Original Music Kyle Gallner Woody Actor, Producer Olivia Thirlby Trudy Actor Brendan Sexton III Nyles Actor Josh Brener Ripley Actor Molly C. Quinn Lillian Actor, Producer Paget Brewster Priscilla Actor Frances Conroy Claiborne Actor Nick Offerman Moses Actor Keegan-Michael Key Proctor Actor Bay Dariz Producer Richard Rawlings Executive Producer Justin Talley Cinematographer Lilly Grabowski Film Editing Patrick Thompson Production Design Heidi Koleto Art Director Brooks Fairley Set Decoration Jessyca Bluwal Costume Design Lauren Grey Casting